This romantic Cathedral Hill institution's primarily Mediterranean cuisine has aroused appetites for 30 years.

(651) 222-9084

374 Selby Ave
St Paul, MN 55102 44.9466 -93.1158

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhood: Summit - University

wafrost.com/home.h…

Reviews & Ratings for W.A. Frost & Company

4 Star Rating: Recommended

30 reviews

What users are saying:

Write a review
Reviews from:
1 Star Rating: Poor

10/01/09

I should of stayed home...

by Jkuf01

W.A Frost & Company has a great atmosphere and ambiance- However, it's not worth much when you are constantly waiting for a drink and an hour for a few appetizers at 10pm. The patio was almost empty.

I get better service from my favorite dive bars. Overpriced, bizarre food and terrible service.

We ordered a cheese tray and a flatbread ahi-tuna appetizer- I'm still sick of crackers. Which is 90% of what we recieved.

  • Pros: Nice Patio
  • Cons: Terrible Service
1 Star Rating: Poor

09/28/09

Worthless happy hour

by dgordanier

I had my stomach all set for late happy hour and I was hungry. The bartender gave me a glass of wine and then ignored me for nearly 20 minutes. There was nothing I could do to catch his eye because it was noisy and he spent all his time way at the other end of the bar flirting with another customer. The only reason I'd see to go back would be that I could get a glass of wine for free, because I seriously could have left without paying and no one would have noticed.

  • Pros: good wine
  • Cons: worthless service
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

09/06/08

WOW!

by ryan507

If you decide to eat here, ask to sit on the patio you will love it! One of my best dinning exp. ever we sat outside on a perfect night, ordered a great drink vodka bootleg. The service was super always is when your server has a helper to do the water and bring the bread out. The food reminds me a lot of what you see on top chef very trendy and up scale! Check this place out!!

  • Pros: patio, great menu, and service!
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

07/21/08

What a special evening

by hansonm69

I took my date to this restaurant for her birthday. We had 7pm reservations and were seated right away. The dining rooms looked full but not crowed and we felt very comfortable in our corner. My date was wished happy birthday by our attendants which made her feel special. We were served promptly but we never felt rushed. We started with the Tapas Trio which was an excellent combination of shrimp, beef and salmon bites each with their own delicious seasoning. Peaches our my dates favorite fruit so she loved the fennel and peach salad with crumbed blue cheese and walnuts while I had a simple mixed green salad. We both had the filet which was also out of this world. My date loves red meat if it is not red but I like mine on the rarer side. Both were cooked to perfection and hot at the same time. They melted in out mouths. The filet was served on a bed of mascarpone herb polenta and mushroom ragout that was very good. We finished off our meal with the Mini Trio Plate for dessert which was also an excellent combination of creme brulee, strawberry-rhubarb cobbler and dark chocolate cherry cake . My date had a very good port to go with her dessert. We felt like we could linger and enjoy finishing our drinks and talking for as long as we wanted. I would recommend this restaurant.

  • Pros: pleasent staff, ambience
  • Cons: small parking lot
4 Star Rating: Recommended

03/08/08

Best patio in the twin cities

by easton6

My wife and I love W.A Frost. It is always our first choice for date night. We especially love it at the bar - always great service and the bar menu is great food to share in a more relaxed setting. Our current favorite is the BLT with fries - it is so good. We highly recommend the bar for a great dinner or a relaxing drink. Can a brag about the patio in March? The patio is the best in the twin cities.

  • Pros: great service & great ambiance
  • Cons: it is a popular place, Valet parking is great on the weekend
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

01/29/08

best service, top notch flavors, cozy romantic ambiance

by gte081h

We called ahead and made reservations for our 2nd wedding anniversary. The staff wished us as we entered and got us the best spot on the floor by the fire. Our waiter was very knowledgeable about the food. We ordered their goat cheese pizza which just melted in our mouth, so heavenly, then got the cauliflower soup which was even better, absolutely smooth and drizzled with a sundried tomato pesto oil, just delicious. For salad, we had the beet/goat cheese, it had a yum dressing and was excellent. My husband had the fish for maincourse and cleaned his plate clean! after all that before. I had a yaki soba with leek preparation which was alright, the waiter noticed my reaction and just took it off our bill!!! It was good but he wanted me to say it was excellent :) Our dessert - a perfect not too sweet, pumpkin cake with spiced icecream and a pistachio cream. I cant praise this place enough. They were so mindful and the decor was warm, cozy, perfect for a romantic date.

  • Pros: best service, top notch flavors and a very warm cozy ambiance
  • Cons: none
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

01/28/08

Impressive Chef's tasting menu and a great date night location...

by hillwood

I took my husband here for his birthday. I had zero expectations and turned out to be extremely happy with my choice to take him here. The environment is dark and homey with a subtle hint of your grandma's tchotchke-filled parlor. I assumed it was dressy but people were there in jeans and sweatshirts and it didn't seem to be a problem. Ask for a table by the fireplace or along the back windows for maximum privacy and romance. We had the 6 course chef's tasting menu with wine pairings. It was expensive but when you see what you get, it's a great value. Delicious food we were talking about days later and very nice wine pairings. You get an amuse bouche (+ wine), a fish course (+ wine), a fowl course (+ wine), a meat course (+ wine), a cheese course (+ wine) and a dessert (+ wine). Despite all the courses and wines, you leave pleasantly satiated rather than painfully overstuffed. We made the mistake of ordering cocktails before dinner so by the time we got to the fowl dish, we were googly-eyed. I dreamt of the duck with apples last night, it was so good. We were seated by the server's path to the bar and even the bar food looked delicious. Service was very nice and unobtrusive. Our server was able to answer any questions we had. Food was delivered promptly and we never felt rushed. Can't wait for the weather to get good so we can dine al fresco on their patio.

4 Star Rating: Recommended

01/02/08

Great location and ambience.

by hoopsguy

I've been here twice, both times were related to an anniversary, and both times were great. The lighting and decor is very warm and romantic. The service is excellent from all of the staff and the food is just delicious and well presented. I haven't eaten anything bad there. The parking is somewhat limited in this St. Paul neighborhood, but that's the only real downside to this restraurant.

  • Pros: Food and service
  • Cons: Parking
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

01/01/08

Great restaurant!!

by tdtibbetts

My husband and I enjoy every minute spent at W.A. Frost. We've always had great food, great service, and enjoy the wonderful ambiance!! Good job W. A. Frost!! We'll be back again and again!

  • Pros: Ambience!!
  • Cons: Parking is limited
2 Star Rating: Below Average

12/26/07

Bland, bland, bland

by scons

We went to WA Frost for the first time in late November for our Anniversary. It was a Saturday night and the restaurant was not too busy but the service was quite slow. The best part of the whole meal was the ambiance and the beauty of the interior since the food was horrible. My husband ordered the seafood stew and I ordered the fish special. Our food was cold and was incredibly bland. It did not appear that much thought went into the seasoning and preparation of the dishes. Thank goodness the martinis were good. I would consider going back and giving it one more chance for the ambiance alone but was really not impressed with my first visit.

  • Pros: Ambiance, martinis
  • Cons: Food not good, service slow and unattentive

Showing 1-10 of 25 reviews

Lists In St. Paul

Advertisement

Best of Citysearch

Things To Do Nearby W.A. Frost & Company

Recent Reviews In St. Paul

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Cossetta Italian Market

211 Seventh St W, St Paul, MN

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Cossetta Italian Market

211 Seventh St W, St Paul, MN

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Downtowner Cafe

253 Seventh St W, St Paul, MN

1 Star Rating: Poor

Great Waters Brewing Co

426 St Peter St, St Paul, MN

Advertisement