(651) 698-0353

57 Hamline Ave S
Saint Paul, MN 55105 44.9398 -93.1571

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhood: Macalester - Groveland

GREENMILL.COM

Reviews & Ratings for Green Mill Brewing Co

4.5 Star Rating: Recommended

19 reviews

What users are saying:

Write a review
Reviews from:
1 Star Rating: Poor

11/06/08

Experience with Pizza toppings that had gone bad

by ErinEW

We have loved this pizza in the past, and don't get to treat ourselves out to dinner much any more with two small children, could not wait to have a Deep Dish pizza delivered. We created our own, portabella mushrooms, goat cheese and spinach, we've gotten it before and loved it. This time, something didn't taste right, we couldn't put a finger on it until about halfway through our first pieces, then I found the culprit. It seems the portabellas had gone bad. When we called the restaurant they said they would not refund our money but would send a gift card for the amount of the pizza $26. The mail from there to my home should take 2 days, it's been 4 and we're waiting for the refund, I'm not expecting to get it either. Truthfully, I don't want to eat there again so don't even think I would use it anyway. Rip off!

08/08/08

Local pizza chain continues to bring in droves of families and friends with gourmet pies and pastas.

by Contributor

In Short
From sports fans whooping it up at the bar to kids playing at tables and high booths, Green Mill is a rambunctious scene. The decor is surprisingly nice, given the family-friendly vibe: mahogany wood paneling, decorative glass dividers, brick walls and artsy glass light sconces. Most everyone comes for the pizza, whether it's deep-dish, stuffed or on a cracker-thin seasoned crust. Other dishes include seafood pastas and hot Italian subs.

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

06/01/05

Great pizza & awesome beer

by kestondoswell

Green Mill in St Paul has the best pizza around, bar none. Any and all of their toppings are fresh and delectable. I usually think salads are a waste of time, but the GM cobb salad is to die for. They also have heavenly wings and plenty of delicous, micro-brewed beer to wash it all down with. The staff has always been friendly to me. I don't like the new humongous TV's in there, and all the expansions they're opening up make me fear that they're trying to become like Friday's and the other strip-mall stink-holes. As long as the St Paul one remains the same, that's the one I'm going to. I wouldn't recommend the steak.

  • Pros: Pizza, Beer, Friendly waitstaff
1 Star Rating: Poor

01/28/05

Grumpy Staff

by adamsheridan

We waited too long to be served, and had to hear a busboy complain about how he hated serving families with small children as we sat there with our one-year-old. Too crowded, not effecient, too many TVs, and the food was mediocre.

  • Cons: disorganized, unfriendly
3.5 Star Rating: Average

06/03/03

Accept no imitations

by avatar

This is the only Green Mill you should ever go to. The rest are merely corporate wanna-be knock-off travesties. This Green Mill makes fantastic pizza and has a good selection of beers.

The decor is unique among Green Mills and does not conform to the standard suburban strip mall incarnation of this chain.

When I went here the pizza was served hot, and to my specifications in a timely fashion. Is there anything more you could really want?

  • Pros: Food, Beer
  • Cons: City Parking
3 Star Rating: Average

03/29/03

warm and welcoming

by battistini

I enjoyed this bar/pizzeria. Its televisions are numerous and modern, the atmosphere is woody and friendly. Families with small children are the perfect antidote for any loneliness. The beer selection is very limited (it only offers its own bland creations) but the menu is large. Wings and quesadillas were tasty, desert was mediocre. Surprisingly, the pizza I had was awful. My topping was so scarce the bartender had to take it off the bill. But he missed the point, the whole pizza was a mistake.

  • Pros: atmosphere, large menu
  • Cons: pizza, beer selection
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

02/10/03

Green Mill Pizza!

by lafemale

Oh My God. It is divine. There is a Green Mill Pizza in Brainerd, Minnesota, the lakes area - two hours north of Minnesota that my friends and I go to whenever we vacation in the area. It is the best. We would not go anywhere else for pizza.

  • Pros: tasty pizza, good drinks, family friendly
  • Cons: sometimes slow servic
4.5 Star Rating: Recommended

01/02/03

awesome

by gak0100

I have ate here approx 2 times & each time it was excellant

The only thing I did not like is the topping limits that you have which they aloow you to put on the pizza.

  • Pros: Good Service, Topping Choices
  • Cons: Topping Limits, Parking
4.5 Star Rating: Recommended

01/02/03

They do it your way!

by val99

Thin, deep, hand-tossed...choose your favorite pizza style at GM. Our fav is the pescara...herbed dough between thin & thick. A plus is there is viewing area to watch the pizza being made & the cooks will give your child a piece of raw dough to play with while you wait! Our favorite pizza spot!

  • Pros: good variety, kid friendly
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

12/06/02

Best Pizza Ever!

by krista1421

There's nothing like a flat mushroom pizza washed down by a Green Mill Kool-Aide!!

Showing 1-10 of 17 reviews

Lists In St. Paul

Advertisement

Best of Citysearch

Things To Do Nearby Green Mill Brewing Co

Green Mill Brewing Co

57 Hamline Ave S
Saint Paul, MN 55105

Recent Reviews In St. Paul

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Cossetta Italian Market

211 Seventh St W, St Paul, MN

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Cossetta Italian Market

211 Seventh St W, St Paul, MN

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Downtowner Cafe

253 Seventh St W, St Paul, MN

1 Star Rating: Poor

Great Waters Brewing Co

426 St Peter St, St Paul, MN

Advertisement