09/25/09

Do not go here for brunch

by shiara

I went here for Sunday brunch with my fiance, we ordered the eggs benedict and the crab cake eggs benedict, mine was mediocre at best, my fiance didn't even finish his, and he eats everything. The prices were high and the food was disappointing. The English muffins tasted like cheap frozen muffins from the local megamart, the eggs were not properly cooked, and the sauce was bland, like it came from a jar. Save your money, go to Salut for their eggs benedict, it is to die for!

• Pros: Cool facade
• Cons: Awful food

08/17/09

Good Service, Not Good Food

by netsoup

I have a culinary background.

I've been to the Lexington twice now, and I would not go again. There are just too many GREAT places out there to waste a penny there.

Each time the food is over cooked, and just nasty.

My Mother likes the place, so that is the reason we dined there this weekend, but I could not see myself going there or recommend it to anyone.

• Pros: Iced Tea was good

10/24/08

Consistently excellent food and service

by averageMinneapolitan

I just attended a large birthday party here, with diners from 4 up to 80 years old, and everyone was extremely well cared for by the friendly and competent staff. Of course I've also dined at the "Lex" in smaller groups, and always found the food and service first rate. But the way they rose to the larger challenge really cemented their reputation, in my mind. They just know how to take care of people. Prices are reasonable for the caliber of cuisine. It may not be adventurous or exotic fare, but what they do, they do well. Highly recommended.

• Pros: Dependably good dining experience.
• Cons: Some may find it a little old-fashioned, I guess.

12/19/07

Exquisite Comfort Food in Unstuffy Elegance

by greekcrone

I was a freshly fledged Ph.D. when, 35 years ago, I came to Saint Paul to interview for a teaching job at Hamline U. To get to know me, the faculty took me to The Lexington, and I must say I was impressed. I got the job and moved to St. Paul. Five years later, I was watching my son perform in his very first band concert at Webster Magnet School. He was in third grade, and he had just gotten his first suit. After the concert, he told me he wanted to go eat at The Lexington. Where he got the idea, I don't know, but it was a great idea. Once more, I was impressed; however, when he ordered the pheasant, I gulped: I was just starting a business and the budget was exceedingly tight. I guess my brain must have clicked into the idea that The Lex was too expensive, because I didn't get back there until a month ago--and then I wondered why I had waited so long. The Lex serves the best crabcakes in town, terrific crispy green beans (how do they do it?), calamari, barbecue. Prices are definitely reasonable! In case you're showing off on a budget, though, here's a tip: go for lunch. The Lex is a great place for romance, business and family celebrations. Few restaurants can handle all that and still be there when you want comfort food in unstuffy elegance.

08/13/07

Great for a family celebration.

by ostrom

We went to the Lexington for a family gathering, 12 of us in all. We had excellent service, although a little slow. Since this was a birthday celebration and we were all visiting, this was fine with us. All of the meals were wonderful - barbecued ribs, walleye almondine, rueben sandwich, turkey dinner - as were the desserts - bread pudding, chocolate cake, cheesecake. This was a wonderful setting for a family celebration.

• Pros: Excellent services, great food.
• Cons: A little slow.

A St. Paul staple since 1935, this is the place to go for momentous occasions.

by Contributor

In Short
The Lexington is a posh watering hole with devotional service in a chandelier-lit dining room. The curving mahogany is the perfect place to order a perfect martini. On any given night, many diners mark important occasions. Traditionally prepared prime rib and chateaubriand are the fanciest menu staples. Fresh fish and pasta specials are also available. The steak and seafood combo includes a petite filet and walleye amandine.

02/18/06

Excellent Restaurant

by rprust

My girlfriend and I went here for Valentines Day, and we were very satisfied. Neither of us had heard of the place before we went, but I had gotten a tip from a coworker. We were pleased that we went here when we left. The food was excellent and fairly reasonable. The service was quick and everyone there was very friendly. The ambience of the place makes for an excellent date spot. They even had two guys playing a violin and accordian there for Valentines Day. It was great. I definitely plan on returning.

• Pros: Great Food, Excellent Service, Great Ambience
• Cons: A little pricey

01/01/06

User review by carssusan

by carssusan

We found ourselves and two friends at a loss as to where to eat on Christmas Eve. We usually have a big family get together, but a recent wedding sent half of the family to a new family. We were lucky to get a reservation for the Lexington and what a great time we had. The crispy beans are wonderful and calamari done to perfection. I had the braised short ribs, delicious, my husband had the chicken pot pie, beautiful and very good. My son had rare Aui Tuna and it was done great. Our friends dishes were very good also. Our service was wonderful and the wine selection was very good. All in all a very nice comfortable night. Thanks for being open.

11/04/05

Wonderful!

by annikan42

I have been the the Lexington three times, and I was impressed every time. The staff is attentive and the food is delicious. They have amazing steaks and the chocolate cake is my favorite desert. It's a little bit pricey, but the food is worth it. It's usually not very crowded either. I will definitely be going back.

• Pros: Parking, Great food

02/14/03

Amazing place

by mjkeliher

This place is wonderful. The food is of the highest order, and the service is outstanding. Nothing but the best all around.

• Pros: Excellent food, Outstanding service, Beautiful atmosphere
• Cons: Somewhat pricey